Hello. This is my first contact with Lemmy, and I’m happy to see that it’s growing faster and faster. However there’s one thing that’s blocking me for now from completely abandoning Reddit after API changes.
There are thousands of various bigger and smaller communities on Reddit. Many of them are participating in the blackout, and more and more are deciding to stay blacked out indefinitely after recent CEO’s memo leak. I was using Reddit for almost 7 years, and before the drama started it was one of my most viewed websites.
For 99,9% of the time spent on Reddit I was lurking and browsing small or small-to-medium sized subreddits - some of them for very specific content, some for various tech or non-tech related communities (like AI or emulation). While a good number of these subreddits already have alternatives on Fediverse, for now most of them are not very active, some of them even empty, and some content related to these communities is buried in larger, more general communities. Another number of subreddits whose doesn’t have alternatives on Lemmy/Kbin have alternative communities on Discord, but on Discord it’s somewhat hard to read live discussions, search options are limited, and some servers tend to be toxic - it’s a messaging platform after all, not discussion and content website.
Don’t get me wrong - as a 3rd party app user myself (Sync FTW) I completely despise planned Reddit API changes and support the blackout, but sometimes I fear that if many users from smaller Reddit communities decide to leave altogether, and if some of them which chose to participate in the blackout indefinitely will not return, then these communities which I watch will just disappear with no easy way to browse and search past content and discussion from them. That being said, Lemmy and Kbin are promising alternatives that shed light for the future, but I’m concerned that some smaller communities will never blow up on there, and will ultimately move to messaging platforms or stay a thing from the past.
There is one good thing though - seeing all those post about planned changes are finally convinced me to get more active on discussions I read, and I hope that Lemmy will appeal to me in this regard.
TL;DR: I fully support Reddit blackout and migration to Lemmy, but I fear that it may spell an end to some smaller and specific communities.
You must log in or register to comment.
Agreed 100% but you also have to remember it took Reddit years to get to that point. You’re losing a community that was already built for you, but you can focus on building it back here in the Fediverse.
So much this. We can’t complain about the lack of content and much smaller communities in the fediverse. It’s up to us to build that. Same as we used to do, just in a different place.
Will it take time? Sure! But the quicker we gain momentum, the easier it will be for other to follow suit.
Let’s do this!
I support this, but I think some Reddit communities will probably take years to rebuild, if most of their users won’t be interested in going to Lemmy in the short term - and that’s what looks to be the case for now in most non-tech communities. Also, I think those moving subreddits which could choose not to continue on Reddit should at least change their status from private to restricted AFTER the blackout, so the users could access archival, often valuable content, for example when searching on Google for answers to specific questions.
And with any luck the money men won’t be able to come in and take our communities here. One thing I am hoping is developed in the next year or two is full portability for Fediverse accounts: the option to easily switch all your posts, comments, messages, and community subscriptions to a new server.
Of course. I don’t remember what Reddit was in the beginning, but I imagine that it was similar to Lemmy instances now.
I had an account there for over 10 years (I think 12, actually? - not going to login and check right now) and yes, as far as I remember it was a very similar start. A bit small. A bit broken. But definitely a similar vibe as to what I’m getting from Lemmy/Kbin
Reddit will survive. But without some if it’s most active users, and without proper mod tools - what’s left will be a wasteland.
No mod wants to open a janky app riddled with ads to delete spam. Which means that Reddit will get more ads, more phishing, more OnlyFans bots, more instances of hate speech and abusive content. All the while, the app will be continuously redesigned so you click on those ads rather than seek information and engage in communities.
Effectively, Reddit will turn into Facebook. That’s the business model they’ve been trying to emulate and that’s what they think is going to generate them money.
It might work and become profitable. And if so, then hey - Spez technically did his job. But at the cost of the world’s great community platform, it’s so damn short sighted.
Reddit is a space where you can learn languages, learn about other cultures, learn how to fix things around the house, share personal music, share art, share stories, make friends, find love, find housing, find recipes, find a fetish, sell stuff, buy stuff, become a celebrity, make a great travel itinerary, find health and fitness resources, adopt a pet, etc.
Pretty soon, all it’ll be good for is validating your racist uncle - all so a few Silicon Valley execs could afford yet another golden toilet.
Reddit will survive. Even if the blackout lasts a long time, other people will create new subreddits to replace the private ones. Or Reddit will replace the mods.
It will survive, yeah, maybe I’m overreacting. But I don’t think it will the same place anymore. It will definitely be shittier.
That’s probably true, but there’s nothing we can do about that, aside from trying to make the alternatives better.
I wouldn’t be so sure. I believe great managers could take it over and rescue it today, but they don’t have great managers, the place is run by idiots. It might survive in the manner Digg survived.
They just made it a lot harder to moderate by sparking an angry powder keg like they did, let alone killing all the mod tooling. That was better than what they’ve managed to produce in almost 20 years. They’ve also lost many of the moderators who weren’t doing it for the money (at least not reddit’s money). They can always hire new moderators, but that’s yet another expense on the earnings statement.
If they can get all the spam and hate posts under control it’s going to be a repost farm and OP will not surely deliver anymore.
From where I’m standing it appears they’ve been given an ultimatum by VC investors who are hellbent on selling whether they lose their asses at the bottom or not.
deleted by creator
Digg didn’t survive though. Right now it looks like a corporate blog with a barely visible comment section.
That’s what I was getting at.
I agree that reddit won’t run out of users. I think the big question is whether they can figure out how to turn a profit.
