Dimmer06 [he/him,comrade/them]

  • 1 Post
  • 57 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 26th, 2020

help-circle

  • Yeah I agree that most of the union workers in the US are not particularly well off. Unions like NEA and UFCW are massive, business-oriented, and many of their members are dirt poor. I think the issue we run into as leftists is that we just sorta dogmatically look at unions as a good thing (or at least Lenin’s century old formulation of them as useful forms of proletarian organization) or we go ultraleft and reject them as colloborators in colonialism and genocide (which isn’t to say they aren’t) with very little insight into the internal contradictions of a union, how they came to be this way, or what a union even is. The lack of democracy and the outright hostility to workers self organizing within the big unions fucks their members over just as their protectionism or militarism fucks the global proletariat over.

    Near where I live for instance there are union members in mills who are frequently ordered to work 24 or more hours in a row and their local has been outright hostile to any sort of strike or activity to fight it. Idk what their contract looks like or how well they’re compensated but they’ve had multiple members killed in car accidents driving home and many more injuries on the job after working for a day straight. These are the “good union mill jobs” everyone’s grandparents had.

    There are of course union workers in military contractors and such that are directly benefiting from Imperialism or other forms of exploitation, but the reason the big unions suck is because they are one degree from state institutions designed to choke out proletarian revolution and democracy, not because their members are all living rich off the blood of the global south and have democratically decided to keep it that way. White collar non-union workers in email jobs are much more likely to be true labor-aristocrats that produce nothing than a UFCW grocery clerk or an NNU Nurse.





  • The big unions are all corrupt as fuck and absurdly top-down and undemocratic. (edit: also a lot of people in the labor movement are grossly incompetent and gullible) This is because they’ve been shaped that way since FDR. The NLRA was designed to turn unions into state sanctioned and controlled institutions and then they were purged of anyone who had ideological commitments to democracy or socialism. From there they were allowed to collect dues from employees working under their contracts even if those employees were not members of the union which meant there was no material reason for them to actually do anything more than win an NLRB run election and a single shitty contract. Then they could embed themselves like ticks in job sites.

    Today most unions are sitting on billions of dollars in pension and insurance funds. Union officials regularly make six figure salaries for nothing while their members make poverty wages. They are blatantly undemocratic institutions in which the members have so little say that the federal government consistently intervenes in elections. The unions do not have any obligation to recruit, educate, agitate, or organize their members. Most of the unions are only interested in getting Democrats elected primarily to fight right to work so that they can continue to extract dues from non-members. The unions also frequently suppress the self activity of their members and make it harder for them to organize and will even collaborate with management to remove problematic workers. When strikes or other actions do happen they happen at the whim of union leadership, not the members. They have been shaped this way by decades of opportunism and US government interference.

    Unions do not have to be this way though. There’s no actual obligation to go through the NLRA process. There’s no obligation to work under the boots of the big unions. We should aim for strategic militancy not timid super-majorities. We should exercise working class power and democracy, not legalistic state power. We should fight like guerillas, not like liberals. Communists in the US should focus more on workers and sow our roots deeper into job sites, but among the 90% of American workers that are not organized in any sort of union who are generally the most proletarian workers, not among the 10% who are in unions. We should not seek to join bigger unions that will stamp us out. We and should replicate the successes of the CIO ninety years ago. If we are in the big unions already we should be organizing within them as communists, forming caucuses along our political orientations and tactically supporting reform efforts.


  • I like to try and believe most people are fundamentally good but your median American is probably casually racist and misogynistic (and all around an ignorant bigot). They don’t want to vote for a woman or a POC even if they might not feel comfortable saying that out loud. To their right only gets worse and the population of voters skews right.

    Of course the Democrats have no real strategy to get around this issue besides running women or POC with further and further right politics which doesn’t seem to be working.

    As leftists we recognize that the solution is building a proletarian class that can either correct the politics of the average proletariat here or crush the proletariat’s enemies here. There’s no magic candidate we can run that will attract masses of workers because there are very few people who self identify as workers in any meaningful sense.



  • American fascism is unique from its European manifestations in that it has firmly consolidated itself in the bourgeois state apparatus and civil society. When European fascism seized power it needed a paramilitary force, dictatorial strongman, and violent purges of “undesirables” because the regime had not consolidated power.

    In US society that consolidation happened long ago though. The US regime keeps its “undesirables” in a constant state of precarity, ghettoization, and incarceration and only occasionally ramps up the genocide to mass killings. It’s paramilitary base has been incorporated into the state as it’s police force. The US regime allows a carefully controlled facade of Democracy because it does not need a strongman. The US regime allows limited leftist ideas to proliferate and act as long as they do not constitute a threat.

    Many leftists who claim to worry about the “threat of fascism” are actually worried about the existing fascism burning hotter than it currently does - and they’re not necessarily wrong to do so - but any analysis that worries about some incoming fascism on the horizon without realizing the disease is already here will be fatally flawed.


  • The first big question is if you’re public sector or private. If you are public employees then you do not have collective bargaining rights under Texas law which means there would be no union certification election or contract. This doesn’t mean you can’t take action and win changes, but it will not be easy and will require strong solidarity and militancy.

    If you are private sector then you can go through the NLRB process if you choose, but you are not obligated to.

    The big unions you would want to talk to are the National Educators Association (or a local thereof), The AFL-CIO (who will probably put you in touch with American Federation of Teachers), SEIU, or the Teamsters. If these unions were to work with you they would probably urge you to take less militant routes, but will have lots of resources that they might dedicate to your campaign.

    Alternatively you could reach out to a smaller more radical organization like the IWW, United Electrical Workers, or EWOC that would be more supportive of radical action but wouldn’t really be able to dedicate much to your effort.

    Ultimately the resources a large union contributes mean very little to a union effort compared to the organization, solidarity, and militancy of the workers and their community though. All of the lawyers in the world will not win your demands. The best thing you can do right now is form a small committee of the coworkers who most seriously want to organize and interview with these organizations and democratically pick the one that feels best. Don’t be scared of going independent either if your committee is unsure of who to work with or if these organizations refuse to work with you.


  • I think the clearest indication of how weak the left is in the US is the incredibly superficial understanding of the labor movement in this country and the contradictions within it. Just total ignorance of how the big unions constantly fight each other, fuck each other over, and screw over the broader working class, oftentimes for the pettiest nonsense. They’re all more than happy to sell out the most vulnerable and isolated workers if it means a slightly quicker deal with bosses and the collection of dues money.

    This doesn’t even touch on the fact that a lot of these unions are full of white collar workers that we would probably condemn individually as social fascists but then they go on strike and we celebrate it for some reason.

    I’m sorry you got screwed by this. I hope you can find decent work somewhere soon.




  • Speaking as a former DSA member, I would probably now advise against joining them. The org is split between right wing opportunists operating in bad faith and guileless leftists who constantly get run over by the right. If you were to join I’d say don’t give dues to the national, join Red Star, support the IC, and push for open hostility towards the right wing of the organization. The one thing DSA has got going for it is that they’re big and can probably connect you to work you’re interested in (until the NPC steamrolls you for not being a lib).

    PSL seems cool from an outsid perspective. My one problem with them is they don’t seem to have a great analysis of the US labor movement but there’s basically no organization in the US that does so it can’t count against them too much. PSL split off of Workers World which I personally think has a much better news site/paper but doesn’t seem have as much of a presence on the ground. Both organizations seem to have similar politics in the Marcyite vein though.


  • IANAL nor do I know the specifics of Texas’s laws but I would encourage her to only communicate about it over encrypted channels whose designers will not comply with Texas’ laws and delete any communications about it that are not encrypted. She should do her research on where to go with a VPN. She should make sure her phone or any other device is not tracking her location. She should tell nobody and lie to anyone she needs to provide a justification to. She should pay in cash for as much as possible. If they’ll need her medical records she should have them printed off and deliver them herself. Afterwards she should destroy all physical and digital evidence that she can. She should also never talk to law enforcement without her lawyer present.

    My guess is that they aren’t actively hunting people who leave the state for reproductive care but if she does all that it would awfully hard to convict her even if they were aggressive about it.


  • In the US more people than any any other state in history (save for the worst period of Nazi Germany) are kept as basically slaves in jails and prisons on drug charges and they are loaned out to capitalists. A significant section of the underclass is held down by drug use where they are sedated both personally and politically, forced into the worst jobs, or the reserve army of labor.

    This isn’t a conspiracy though. Like the prisons aren’t conspiring with the cartels. It’s all just capitalists trying to make money by screwing someone else over and seeing both extremely vulnerable drug producers and drug users and taking advantage of them. Capitalism rewards this so it’s reproduced until it isn’t possible to squeeze any more juice out of it.